January 30, 2011

Gint's Pull-List Review 1-26-11

Another light week for the ol’ Pull-List. Three books this week: Action Comics #897, Green Arrow #8 and Wonder Woman #606.

While last week’s comics were harder to rate due to a high quality of each, the week of January 26 presents us with a lesson in mediocrity.


Our winner this week…

Green Arrow #8

… barely.

I’ve enjoyed Green Arrow so far. J.T. Krul has been doing a good job with the writing and Diogenes Neves’ art has been passable. This issue however was just kind of boring.


Instead of furthering the plot (which I’m sure it did in some small way) it just tells a story about goings on in the Star City forest. It was a cool story, but nothing awe inspiring.


And I hate reading Etrigan and that damn rhyming speech.


Our runner up…

Action Comics #897

This has been a strange arc. I’m really on the fence about Paul Cornell. Sometimes I think he gets Lex Luthor, and other times I wonder if he’s forgotten who he’s writing.


I thought the search for the Black Rings had a lot of potential, but this arc just isn’t living up to it. At times it just feels like, “Hey, wouldn’t it be cool if Lex faced off against Gorilla Grodd this issue? Lets do it!” It doesn’t feel like there’s a real cohesive story happening here. This latest installment is no different.


And easily finishing in last place…

Wonder Woman #606

Its just impossible for me to get into the new direction of Wonder Woman without bias. I’m really trying, but its not working out.


This story might be cool if it was introducing a brand new character or if it was clearly an Elseworlds tale. But its not. Its in-continuity Wonder Woman and I can’t justify it. The whole time I’m reading it I can’t help but think, “It’ll be over soon and we’ll get back to real Wonder Woman stories.”


I’m keeping my fingers crossed that it happens sooner rather than later.


-Gint


Ps: I don’t care if the new outfit is similar to the old one. And while I don’t want to be one of “those” fans, I want the traditional outfit back. I know a warrior princess wouldn’t really run around in a glorified bathing suit. But its fucking comic books for Christ’s sake. Give her the iconic one.


January 23, 2011

Gint's Pull List Review 1-20-11


This was a tough one this week. Three really good books. Even the new team on Supergirl came to play. But it was Brightest Day #18 that won the week.


Geoff Johns and Peter Tomasi know what they’re doing. A couple early issues bounced around a little too much, but they soon got it under control and started giving each storyline more of each issue.


The Hawkman/Hawkgirl storyline isn’t my favorite storyline in Brightest Day, but it was done well this issue and brought to somewhat of a conclusion. It doesn’t hurt that I love seeing Carol Ferris. And it breaks my heart when her and Hal long for each other. I’m a softee like that.


The Deadman/Dove storyline was also advanced. At this point though, I’m ready for the White Ring to quick fucking with Deadman. I also think his and Dove’s "getting it on" is a little creepy. But kudos to Boston Brand I guess.


Congratulations to Supergirl #60 for coming in second. As I stated, there was some hesitance to buy this issue. The Sterling Gales/Jamal Igle run on Supergirl was pretty super and a new creative team is sometimes like rolling the dice. Writers Nick Spencer and James Peaty acquitted themselves quite well in my humble opinion. They introduced some new characters and made them likeably unlikeable. They also wrote strong characterizations of Supergirl and Lois Lane. A MUCH better interpretation of Lois than what we got it Superman #707.


I knew Bernard Chang’s artwork wasn’t going to be an issue. I don’t think he’s too highly regarded by most of nerd-dom, but I’ve loved his work since he did some Wonder Woman issues with Gayle Simone. Plus he draws pretty girls.


The combo of writers and artist blended with each other well and did a great job with the alternating storylines toward the end of the book.


I’m interested. After Paul Cornell on Action Comics and Jeff Lemire on Superboy, I’ve been a little wary of these new writers. One issue in and Spencer and Peaty have earned themselves an A.



And lastly, Green Lantern Corps #56. Don’t let it’s 3rd place finish fool you. It was a good book. This arc has been much more enjoyable than the first, but matched up against Brightest Day #18 and Supergirl #60 its just fell short.


The “The Weaponer” draws to its conclusion well. Sinestro finally shows and kicks some ass as do the rest of the Sinestro Corps. But its Tony Bedard’s characterization of the Green Lanterns that I don’t care for. Literally. When Tomasi was writing it I felt for the rest of the Corps. I was all in emotionally. But something is falling flat with Bedard’s writing. He’s just not making me give a shit about this new crew.


Maybe he’s still finding his way? I hope so.


January 21, 2011

Joe Q's Top 10 Achievements‏

On January 4th 2011, Marvel Editor-in-Chief, Joe Quesada stepped down from the post he had held since 2000. Although he will still maintain his role with the company as Chief Creative Officer of Marvel Entertainment, his departure from E.I.C. marks the end of an era. The 2000s was a decade in which the Marvel brand saw vast expansion in both traditional comics as well as various other sources of media. In recent years Quesada has come under fire from fans for his many controversial decisions regarding some of the House of Ideas' most sacred properties. This list however, is not about any of the negative things Joe had a hand in, but highlighting the positive things he had direct or indirect influence over.


10. Restoring the "Original" Numbering

In an effort to artificially boost sales numbers, Marvel's then E.I.C. Bob Harras cancelled and restarted all of Marvel's titles that were either not X-Men related or under the 100 issue mark. It was a band-aid that did not address the real problem of that era: the stories were awful. Years of bad storylines like "The Clone Saga" and "Heroes Reborn" had scared away once loyal Marvel readers and the false excitement of a #1 issue was not going to bring them back. When Quesada took over at the beginning of the decade, one of the first steps he took was to reinstate the original numbering that many of the classic titles had lost due to this ill-conceived publicity stunt. This was not the biggest move per say, but an act of good faith that went a long way with me as a reader.


9. The Civil War

No, not the yankees and rebels. I'm talking registered and unregistered heroes! After the 90s, The Big M took a few years break from "event" stories that encompassed the entire Marvel U. The success of the "House of M" storyline emboldened the publisher to push forward with another universe-wide story focusing on the attempt to have heroes register with the United States government and the division in the super hero community caused by this. Civil War set in motion events like the "Death of Captain America" and "One More Day," a Spider-Man storyline that retconned the past 30 years of Spider-Man's history. While these 2 events may not have been great achievements under Joe Q's watch, the Civil War in itself was a solid and imaginative storyline that was an example of how good a crossover could be.


8. Marvel Knights Imprint

Introduced as a line of books that dealt with more mature themes than the regular Marvel Universe, Marvel Knights was the first attempt to contend with DC's wildly popular Vertigo line. In years to come the Marvel MAX imprint would take the place of Knights and present even darker, grittier stories, but the Knights line was the first to handle traditional properties in a slightly more adult manner. Two of the most successful books to come out of this line would be The Punisher, with the creative team of Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon, fresh off their award winning run on Preacher, and Daredevil, featuring filmmaker Kevin Smith as writer and Quesada himself providing top-notch art. Smith's run on the title was highly regarded among fans and critics and helped legitimize comics as a form of entertainment that could attract top level creative talent. In the years that followed many other creators from film and tv took shots at writing comics, but it all started with Smith's take on a blind lawyer in Hell's Kitchen.


7. Avengers Disassemble/New Avengers

For years Marvel had longed to make The Avengers a flagship title much like DC's Justice League of America. It took the total dismantling of the team by Brian Micheal Bendis and David Finch to make this happen. A new team featuring some of Marvel's most recognized characters was "assembled" following a violent break-up of the old team. A twisted plot that would take years to reveal itself to be the seeds of Secret Invasion helped finally place Marvel's mightiest team at the front of reader's pull lists.


6. John Romita Jr. and J. Michael Straczynski's run of Amazing Spider-Man

Peter Parker had fallen on some tough times. The late 90s saw the departure of many of the signature creators that had made Spider-Man one of the most popular characters of the decade. Silly story lines featuring the faked death of Aunt May and the aforementioned "Clone Saga" had soured many hard core fans of the title. In June of 2001 the creative team of Straczynski and Romita Jr. would give Amazing Spider-Man the shot of adrenaline it so desperately needed. With a slightly different take on Mr. Parker's spider-like powers and the introduction of new villains, this once stale franchise was once again fresh and exciting.


5. Grant Morrison and New X-Men

Yes, I'll say it, Grant Morrison's work on New X-Men was great. With the release of the X-Men film, Marvel felt pressure to deliver a book that resembled the slick dressed, science fiction based heroes of the silver screen. And what better individual to call on then the unconventional author of WE3. The success of New X-Men cemented Morrison's status as a creator who's name alone could boost the sales of a title. The introduction of Beast's second mutation, the addition of Emma Frost to the team and the (wait for it) death of Jean Grey are events that still shape today's X-books.


4. Emphasizing the Trade Paperback

Some say that putting a system in place to release almost every storyline from Marvel's collection of titles was a misstep. But the sales figures would suggest that it helped grow the influence and reach of all comics. With the availability of more stories in non-traditional comic outlets the causal fan could easily be turned into the consistent fan. The sales numbers don't lie.


3. The Ultimate Universe

The comics bubble of the 1990s had burst, and facing financial and creative bankruptcy bold action was needed. Introduced in 2000, The Ultimate imprint was launched to the hopes of securing new, young readers by updating and reinventing many of the properties that had been created in the 1960s and 70s. The Ultimate U. would also serve as the launching pad for great creators such as Brian Michael Bendis, Mark Millar and Byran Hitch, who all would have large contributions to the publisher over the decade.


2. The Origin of Wolverine

It was long thought of as "the story that could never be told". The origin of Wolverine had been kept in the dark since the characters creation, mainly because it was widely believed that the mystery was much more appealing then the actual story could ever be. One of Quesada's main messages as E.I.C. was to be bold and I can think of no other move that was bolder then green lighting the telling of this tale. Wolverine: Origin was a hit with fans and critics alike and proved once and for all that there is no story in comics that "can not be told".


1. X-Men: The Movie

After the creative exodus of the early 90s, Marvel was faced with the difficult problem of maintaining it's fanbase. Even the most successful properties like the "X" titles felt the decline in sales. Ill fated attempts at re-energizing this brand included X-Treme X-Men, the Onslaught Saga, and many other odd ideas. What the X franchise needed was a return to the roots of what made it appealing to so many people. Ironically, it took a feature film to light the way.

Marvel had a less then impressive track record with translating their properties to live action. From the 70's Spider-Man TV series to Dolph Lundgren in The Punisher, it seemed that these heroes were meant to stay in the comic shops. But 1998's Blade proved this theory wrong and director Bryan Singer saw this as a sign that given the right focus, a superhero story could work. X-Men: The Movie focused heavily on the theme of a discriminated group and the different ways individuals of this group handle it. With parallels to Martin Luthor King and Malcolm X, this version of X-Men also highlighted the science fictional elements of the story. Excellent casting, acting and believable effects all contributed to a movie that not only appealed to the hardcore fan but the mainstream as well. With the influx of new and returning fans linked to the success of the film, Marvel took advantage changing creative teams and directions on not just the X-Men, but many of their monthly titles. While Joe Quesada certainly did not have a huge hand in the production of the X-Men movie, he took full advantage of the renew interest in Marvel's rich portfolio of properties.


January 20, 2011

Gint's Pull List: 1-20-11

Welcome to the first official Gint's Pull List. In this blog I'll be projecting my hopes for the books of the week and seeing how they finish up once I read them.

Supergirl #60
We'll read Supergirl with a little trepidation. This is the first issue for new writers Nick Spencer and James Peaty. Seeing how the old team of writer Sterling Gates and artist Jamal Igle were the first people to get me interested enough in Supergirl to buy her book, Spencer and Peaty have some lofty expectations to live up to.



Green Lantern Corps #56
Tony Bedard's "The Weaponer" arc has been infinitely better than the previous one. Perhaps it took an arc to get his legs in the universe of the Green Lanterns. I still miss Patrick Gleason on art, but Tyler Kirkham has been solid.





Brightest Day #18
Johns and Peter Tomasi. My bread and butter. While some parts have been slow and uninteresting, the whole has been a solid story. I'd like more Aquaman and Martian Manhunter, but I shouldn't complain since at least they're alive again.



I predict Brightest Day will be the winner in this week of 3 should be-solid books. Supergirl is the real wild card. Best of luck to Spencer and Peaty. We'll see you once I read them.

-Gint

January 2, 2011

4-2-10 I Hate You, Fill-In Artist













Now, though it may not seem like it, I mean no disrespect toward Scott Clark and Ibraim Roberson. But when you get 6 whole issues of Mauro Cascioli's gorgeous artwork then need fill-ins for the climax of the story, anyway you slice it, its a let-down.


The new art wasn't awful, but in contrast with Cascioli's, it was. In the heat of the moment I may have burned this issue to ashes.

-Gint

3-30-10 Semantics
















True story. My penchant for devil worship was called out in a parent/teacher conference in high school. Catholic high schools apparently aren't approving of the devil on ANY level.


-Gint


3-23-10 Some Creepy Shit




















While is has yet to kill anyone, there IS a spider of Shelob-type proportions at the office. Just going in there every day has become a test of wills.

-Gint


3-16-10 A Fine Appreciation












Some of us are just lucky that way.

-Gint


3-12-10 Missed Opportunities



























It surprises me that there aren't more arguments about the Green Lantern and Nova Corps being essentially the same peace-keeping force in each Corps respective Universe. Fuck JLA/Avengers. THIS is the company crossover I want to see.


-Gint

Ps This strip is best viewed with the Starsky & Hutch theme playing in the background.